The problem with this false Green Economy starts with the assumption that Nature’s processes can be effectively managed as commodities. Today's biggest ecosystem services markets, the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), has entirely failed to bring down carbon emissions while creating new financial markets and profit opportunities. The false green economy project is built on the staggering philosophical error that assumes that the economy is of greater importance than the ecological system on which the economy depends. By permitting ecosystem services to be sold to the highest bidder (therefore subject to destruction by industrial processes) it assumes that forests, species, stable climates, etc. are somehow replaceable.
Nature’s processes cannot be safely disaggregated. Ecological systems are not fragmented but are complex webs of interconnected and interdependent relations that cannot be effectively understood – much less managed in isolation. Reducing the value of nature to financial terms is an epistemological prelude to exploitation on a material realm. It's no small thing to bring nature into the space where everything must prove its financial worth. Nature is more complex than what we can capture through financial valuations. Over-simplifying the processes of a system on which we are entirely dependent is entirely foolish.
Philosophical errors spawns further methodological errors in the quantification and financialisation nature’s processes. We simply do not have the scientific capacity to measure all of the life-sustaining services provided by nature. What is possible to know for sure is that there will be no financial system to create this human construct we call money without the benefit of a stable climate, clean water and healthy local ecosystems.
When scientists do fix a price for nature these values are often absurdly low or simply ridiculous. The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity (TEEB) report estimates a total economic value of insect pollination worldwide at €153 billion. It's a high number, but does this number actually reflect the value of pollinating insects? Considering that we are dependent on these 'ecosystem services' and the pollinating insects that are a vital part of these ecosystems, it follows that insects are priceless. Our own survival depends on their survival.
The political problem with the false Green Economy is its ruin of democratic participation in environmental decision-making. In privatizing the commons, the conservation of nature moves from a political sphere to become yet another aspect of modern life subject to the whims of the market. Democratic control of development agendas will no longer be possible as markets become the space where environmental decisions are made. Those making decisions become those with the financial clout to participate (i.e. corporations and the financial sector).
The false Green Economy is an intensification of the long trajectory of the enclosures of the commons. This state supported transfer of common land from commoners to politically powerful elites has occurred over several centuries. The Indigenous People’s Kari-Oca 2 Declaration at Rio+20 describes the Green Economy as ‘a continuation of colonalism… a perverse attempt by corporations, extractive industries and governments to cash in on Creation by privatizing, commodifying and selling off the Sacred and all forms of life and the sky’. The Green Economy is the commodification of life itself. We, the people and the earth that we inhabit, are a community – not commodities ripe for exploitation.
The false Green Economy is attractive to the financial and corporate sectors as it creates new areas for market growth in the global commons. Contrary to the environmental rhetoric used to sell this project, in no way does this agenda offer a solution to the biodiversity and mass extinction crises. Instead, the programme uses the ecological crisis as an opportunity for extracting even greater profit from ecological systems. Nevertheless, the UN (and especially the UK) is pressing ahead with the commodification of nature. Nature is being redefined as ‘natural capital’ as a prelude for the intensification of its exploitation. The same innovative but opaque financial mechanisms responsible for the economic crisis will be transferred to already endangered ecological system. The earth – the material, geo-physical context that makes social and economic systems possible – is necessarily the final frontier for capitalism.
Resources on the False Green Economy can be found here.Tweet